So the other day our friend Brandon came over for a night of videogames and general debauchery. I met Brandon through my boyfriend, and we have this interesting and endlessly entertaining relationship where about 85% of our exchanges are insults, put-downs and death threats. It’s not uncommon for us to graphically explain to the other how we plan on taking their life whenever we’re in the same room. I’m sure a big part of it is my subconscious, animalistic female reaction to their videogame bromance, but I digress…
So anyway, Brandon comes over and I ask them what they want me to make for dinner. Keith (the bee eff) recommended I take another stab at the chicken parm I’d made a few nights earlier. I really liked how it turned out at the time, but already knew once I tasted it that there were a few things I’d do differently if I made it a second time around.
I get ready to walk a block to the Ralphs and Keith and Brandon come with me because Brandon tells me he has a dairy allergy so the “parm” part of the chicken parm probably wouldn’t go over too well. I tell him I’ll just skip the cheese part. He then tells me he “is also allergic to whey and hates tomatoes.” I threaten him with death and start to brainstorm ways to cook him a separate piece of chicken.
As we walk to the store I ask him what exactly whey is. Apparently, it’s something they use to churn butter? And they put it in a ton of things for added flavor or syrup or something? All I remember is that he said they had it in the McDonald’s lemonade and he was sick for like 8 days. So no whey (haha…no way…get it?) and no dairy. So I get all my ingredients to make chicken parm and Brandon’s seasoned, baked chicken breast.
So there I am in the kitchen an hour or so later. I make the tomato sauce from scratch, let it simmer, defrost the chicken and slice the mozzarella. I pull out the pan, lay down Keith and my pieces of chicken on one side and Brandon’s whey- and dairy-less piece seasoned with vegetable oil and poultry seasoning on the other. It’s really cute. Like, goldie-locks-and-the-3-bears cute. One side of the tray has two chickens, the other a specially made chicken. I’ve triple checked each ingredient that’s gone into his and I’m feeling proud. About 30 minutes later, the chicken is ready, I’ve dished it up, and presented it to them with pride. Brandon tells me he “really appreciates” that I went out of my way to make him a special kind of chicken and I’m proud.
So we’re eating. It was absolutely amazing. I’m just spacing out and nomming my creation when Brandon says, “Hey Kelsey, are you sure you didn’t put anything in this?”
I think he’s messing with me, in typical Brandon style. “Why?” I ask, “Is it so delicious you can’t believe I made it without any dairy or whey?”
But his face doesn’t change. He means it. “No, I just, I have this feeling. I…I can’t explain it to someone who doesn’t have allergies.”
James, Keith’s room mate and the one who told me to put a spoon under my lip while chopping onions, enters the room and offers Brandon a Benadryl. Brandon shakes his head. James lingers in the doorway just in case.
“Well, what all went in it?” Brandon asks. I rack my brain. I even restarted his chicken by rinsing it off completely with water when I realized that the bread crumbs I was using to season it had whey listed as one of its ingredients.
“Just…vegetable oil and this poultry seasoning. And neither of those things have whey in them, right?” I ask.
Everyone looks back and forth at each other.
“Well,” I ask, “What happens if you eat whey?” I’m expecting him to say that he gets a bad stomach ache for a few days like a few lactose-intolerant people I know.
“If I eat whey I can’t breathe.”
The room goes even more silent. “Oh.”
“Yeah. I almost died when I was like 4 because I ate a whole funnel cake. They had to take me to the ER and inject me with straight insulin.”
“Whoa,” James says, “That’s like…”
“Pulp Fiction status.” We all chime in.
At this point I’m laughing nervously and trying to play it off as another playful death-related antic between Brandon and I. Except this time I’m actually killing him and I don’t know how.
Suddenly I think of something. “Well, I cooked yours in the same oven as ours. And in the same pan.”
…
It was like the face-palm heard ‘round the world.
…
Brandon turns to look at James. “Yeah, I think I will take that Benadryl actually.”
They all then proceed to tell me that things cooked in the same pan will probably end up mixing at some point (even if, visually, there appears to be no cross-over). Brandon was able to fight off his untimely death by not eating any more chicken, taking the Benadryl, drinking about half a litre of water and eating several pieces of a sourdough bread loaf he’d brought with him from home. So the rest of the night Keith and I split Brandon’s rejected poison chicken, and Keith then downed his chicken parm so quickly that he ended up choking and had to force himself to throw up in the bathroom to dislodge the baked, breaded goodness from his epiglottis.
So long story short. Cook someone’s specially prepared food in a completely different area. And my chicken parm is, quite literally, to die for.